CASE COMMENT FORMAT
Case Citation
-
Title: Full case name (e.g., Roe v. Wade).
-
Court: The court that decided the case.
-
Year: The year the decision was made.
-
Citation: Official case citation.
​
Introduction
-
Brief Overview: A concise summary of the case background.
-
Legal Issues: The primary legal questions or issues involved.
Facts of the Case
-
Parties Involved: Identify the plaintiff(s) and defendant(s).
-
Relevant Facts: Key facts and events that led to the legal dispute.
-
Procedural History: The case’s journey through the courts until reaching the current level.
Legal Issues
-
Issue Statements: Clearly formulate the legal issues or questions that the court needed to resolve.
-
Importance: Explain why these issues are significant.
Court’s Decision
-
Holding: The court’s decision on each legal issue.
-
Rationale: The reasoning and legal principles the court used to arrive at its decision.
Legal Reasoning
-
Majority Opinion: Summary of the majority opinion’s legal reasoning.
-
Dissenting/Concurring Opinions: Summary of any dissenting or concurring opinions, if applicable.
-
Statutes and Precedents: Key statutes and previous cases cited by the court in its decision.
Impact of the Case
-
Legal Precedent: How the decision affects future cases and legal principles.
-
Social and Political Impact: Broader implications of the decision on society and politics.
Personal Analysis
-
Critical Analysis: Your evaluation of the court’s decision and reasoning.
-
Strengths and Weaknesses: Highlight the strengths and weaknesses in the court’s argumentation.
-
Alternative Outcomes: Discuss any possible alternative outcomes and their potential implications.
Conclusion
-
Summary: Summarize the key points of the analysis.
-
Final Thoughts: Provide any final observations or thoughts on the case.